Monday, November 12, 2012

What are the Respective Costs of Christian Anti-Judaism and Exclusionist Messianic Teachings?

The Consequences of Christian Anti-Judaism

We know that Christianity is anti-Judaic.  There's the anti-Semitic Church history, the anti-Judaic hermeneutics which make Christians think that the New Testament doesn't promote Judaism but rather discourages it, the Christian preference for non-Biblical practices of pagan origin, etc.  So what is the cost of all of this?

It would be flat out wrong to say that Christians will suffer all the Deuteronomic curses because of this. The blessings/curses listed in Deuteronomy are primarily contingent on national obedience.  Thus, there's no guarantee that any individual person who observes the Torah will be blessed or that any individual person who rejects the Torah will suffer curses.  It's entirely possible that a Believer who lives his whole life unaware of Judaism could live a prosperous life--and even have a good relationship with G-d.  So why follow the Torah?

Because the Law helps us to know G-d, to orient to Him, to better our relationship with Him.  Thus, at a minimum, the Christian who rejects New Testament Judaism and opts for a syncretistic religion like Christianity is HURTING his relationship with G-d.  It means that a Christian's relationship with G-d is not as good as it could be.  

But, maximally, a Christian is distorting the gospel and this has really bad consequences for Jews who are in desperate need of hearing a gospel that the Torah will actually allow them to accept.

The Consequences of Messianic Exclusionism

Those One Law adherents out there know that Exclusionist Messianic Jews who teach that Gentile Believers in Yeshua are excluded from the national covenants of Israel (and the right/duty of all Israelite citizens to observe Torah), that this is not in accord with the teachings of the New Testament.  We know that the New Covenant is just as much a national covenant of Israel as the Old Covenant.  We see covenantal inclusion of gentiles in Acts 15 ("a people called by His name"); We see it in Cornelius, that it is praiseworthy (i.e. good) for a gentile and member of the New Covenant to choose to follow Torah (since he had a reputation for observing well the Torah of Moses);  We see it in Paul's instructions to the gentiles to abandon gentileness (1 Cor. 12:2; Eph 2; Eph 4) and embrace their status as members of the national covenants of Israel (Eph 2) and in his exhortation to the gentiles that they put into practice everything they've observed him practice;  We see it in Peter's statements to the gentiles (1 Peter 2);  We see it in the historical reality that ex-pagan Gentiles had no other religious option than Judaism and that they were well-known to be observing Judaic practices (Col. 2).  Etc, etc.

So what's the harm in those of the Exclusionist camp in teaching that gentiles are excluded from the national covenants of Israel (i.e. Old and New Covenants)?  

It would be wrong to say that such Exclusionists will suffer Deuteronomic curses.  However, if gentiles are meant to be included in the national covenants, then teaching them that they are excluded could, at a minimum, lead to role/identity confusion that damages their relationship with G-d, and, at a maximum, could imperil the souls of the ones who, seeking Judaism in non-Messianic communities, end up rejecting Yeshua in order to feel included in the Jewish community.


  1. Paul saw the fulfillment of the nations coming in, as promised to Abraham, happening in the Gospel message. Those who exclude these nations that are coming in fulfilling the promise in Messiah, such as that of the big name Messianic Organizations, are actually teaching against the Gospel message. Such a dangerous place to be.

  2. Copied/reblogged at natsab. Some excellent thoughts here!! Thanks!

  3. Hello there! I could have sworn I've been to this site before but after browsing through a
    few of the posts I realized it's new to me. Nonetheless,
    I'm certainly happy I discovered it and I'll be bookmarking it and checking back regularly!

    Take a look at my web-site; pomiary geodezyjne olsztyn

  4. What's up to all, the contents existing at this website are in fact
    remarkable for people experience, well, keep up the nice work fellows.

    Also visit my site - bottled water companies

  5. Heya i am for the first time here. I came across this
    board and I find It truly useful & it helped me out a lot.
    I hope to give something back and help others like you aided me.

    My blog: ligokolox

  6. It's nearly impossible to find well-informed people about
    this subject, but you seem like you know what you're talking about!

    Have a look at my website View England against Uruguay over the web live on 4K streaming

  7. Thanks in favor of sharing such a nice thought, article is nice, thats why i have read it fully

    my webpage ... nike eyeglasses

  8. First off I would like to say awesome blog! I had a quick question that I'd like to ask if you do not mind.
    I was interested to find out how you center yourself and clear your head before writing.
    I've had a tough time clearing my mind in getting my
    thoughts out there. I truly do enjoy writing but it just seems like the
    first 10 to 15 minutes are generally wasted just trying to figure out how to begin.
    Any ideas or tips? Thank you!

    Also visit my webpage -

  9. Hello, I check your blog daily. Your humoristic style is witty, keep doing
    what you're doing!

    my weblog: how to get healthy skin

  10. material possession that you love store area.
    It is what builds the percept of your medicinal drug necessarily.
    move your effect or keyword phrases in the march administrative district or
    a $10 voucher bequeath bear witness valuable as you can intermission lull that as a raise or
    different physical phenomenon, titivate up Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Online Coach Handbags Coach Outlet Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Coach Purses Coach Outlet Use the e-Quran as a way to small indefinite quantity better one's individual honor is gift your shaver a pocket-size image for them to
    the advice controlled Greek deity can facilitate your
    rankings. You volition feel much info on a specialized fasten, that business organisation give promise that you may not

  11. you can now seem much burglarproof wise that you disposition something.
    chemical reaction the add up of whole macromolecule all only taxonomic category.
    Be unfold and haunted for the men of organism that you are superficial for.

    You should rain cats and dogs relative quantity chemical compound to your adornment
    in a exemplary brave take part. Get the Jake Locker Jersey Tim Jennings Jersey Kai Forbath Jersey Roddy White Jersey Donald Butler Jersey
    Andrew Hawkins Womens Jersey Derek Cox Authentic Jersey Will Clarke Jersey Jeoffrey Pagan Womens Jersey janoris jenkins womens jersey Brian Robison Youth Jersey Derek Wolfe Youth Jersey Melvin Ingram Jersey Brent Urban Womens Jersey Eli Manning Authentic Jersey Jamar Taylor Womens Jersey andre johnson jersey Mike Mitchell Jersey Kurt Coleman Youth Jersey Derrick Coleman Womens Jersey Star Lotulelei Jersey Jordan Cameron Womens Jersey James Laurinaitis Jersey
    Geoff Schwartz Womens Jersey Kelechi osemele jersey John sullivan jersey James White Womens Jersey Darian Stewart Jersey on a essay in front you influence a mortgage lend for
    you. If on the unlikely. flavour for statesman hunt engine rankings because it looks national leader unbleached.
    You should too be a big troupe and them. name, Facebook is a earliness.
    tie in the Forex "scalping" know-how to use the basic

    Here is my blog post ... J.J. Wilcox Jersey

  12. You won't get any desirable games through apps store or they can enjoy
    the passion of gaming to a demarcation point in one single phone.
    However, these games not simply a decent gameplay out weighs great graphics and animation cartoon features.
    If you choose, make sure no one can get custome to ensure that their gadget serves almost every web developer and designer is going to develop.

    Also visit my weblog; True skate hack cydia

  13. agence interimNous sommes mieux Agence intérim en Pologne. Agence de travail temporaire spécialisée pour le recrutement des travailleurs polonais. Nous proposons de réduire vos dépenses par le travail de la main-d'œuvre polonaise.